How a Years-Old Tip Uncovered by a Receptionist Led to the Arrest of the Delphi Murders Suspect

Mar. 15, 2025

A tip that had seemingly gotten lost in the shuffle was found five years after two girls werekilled on an Indiana hiking trail, leading to the arrest of the man now on trial on accusations he murdered them.

The brutal Delphi murders have been extensively covered in the media, leading to thousands of tips in the five years during which police tried to crack the case.

During Allen’s trial, which is ongoing, a witness testified that she saw a tip with the suspect’s name on it.

According to reports fromWLFI,Fox 59and theJournal & Courier,Kathy Shank, a volunteer receptionist, testified that she found the tip in September 2022. It came from Allen, who self-reported that he was on the trail at the time of the murders. But when the tip had been reviewed in 2017, Allen had been cleared.

But the tip caught Shank’s attention, she testified: She was aware that three girls had reported seeing a man on the trail, according to Fox 59, and here was a man admitting that he’d been on the trail during that timeframe.

At that point, she took the tip to the case’s lead detective, the outlets reported. The investigation then centered on Allen.

Want to keep up with the latest crime coverage? Sign up forPEOPLE’s free True Crime newsletterfor breaking crime news, ongoing trial coverage and details of intriguing unsolved cases.

Police arrested Allen after searching his home and said they found several knives and a gun allegedly linked to a bullet found at the scene, theAssociated Pressreported.

Prosecutors have claimed that Allen confessed to the murders during a jailhouse call with his wife,  the AP, CNN and Fox 59 reported. The defense, however, has tried to have the alleged confession tossed, saying that he was in a declining mental state at the time, according to Fox 59.

Last week, defense attorneysfiled a motionasking the judge to allow them to present a theory that Odinists, members of a pagan religion linked with White nationalism, actually committed the murders, theIndianapolis Star,WTHRand Fox 59 all reported.

source: people.com