Katie Holmes Just Wore the Fall-Perfect Flats You Can Get for $80 on Amazon — Plus, Lookalikes from $27

Mar. 15, 2025

Photo:NSTARimages.com

NSTARimages.com

When it comes to outfit-repeating, you can’t have too much of a good thing. Just askKatie Holmes.

The actress has worn Mary Jane flats multiple times in recent months, proving that they’re a necessary addition to any well-appointed shoedrobe. Her most recent look included a pair of Mary Jane flats in gleaming silver — theFranco Sarto Tinsley Mary Jane Flats, to be exact. She styled them with a sheer lace long-sleeve top over a black bra and skinny blue jeans, completing the ensemble with a black flap shoulder bag.

Holmes keeps reaching for Mary Janes; she woreanother silver pairwith an oversized button-down and straight-leg pants in Paris, strolled around New York inpowder blue ATP Atelier Mary Janeswith a tan cardigan and cropped jeans, and pairednavy T-strap Mary Janeswith a midi-length slip dress.Anne HathawayandMandy Moorehave both worn versions of the casual-meets-sophisticated flats, too.

But it’s the silver Mary Jane flats that are really giving us heart eyes right now. While silver shoes sound flashy, they’re actually an elegant and versatile style staple that pair with multiple colors and outfits — take it fromHelen Mirren,Emma Roberts, orJane Fonda, the latter of whom also wore a pair of silver Mary Janes on the red carpet lately.

Thanks to Holmes, we’re now head over heels (well, flats) for a pair of silver Mary Jane flats. If you love the ones she wore, we’ve got good news for you — not only can you snap upher exact Franco Sarto pairon sale for $80 at Amazon, but brands like Coach, Sam Edelman, and Naturalizer have hopped on the trend, too. We found the 10 best silver Mary Janes on Amazon, starting at just $27.

Her exact pair:Franco Sarto Tinsley Mary Jane Flats, $80 (orig. $115)

Franco Sarto Tinsley Mary Jane Flats

Nordstrom

$115$80 at Amazon

If imitation is the most sincere form of flattery, then treating yourself to the exact pair of silver Mary Jane flats Holmes wore is your best bet. These Franco Sarto flats have a square-toe design, thin strap with an adjustable buckle, and subtle stacked heels. Choose from sizes 5–13 with half sizes and wide widths available.

Stunner Square-Toe Mary Jane Flats

Amazon

$29 at Amazon

Let these gleaming silver Mary Jane flats peek out from beneath a maxi skirt or wide-leg jeans. The square-toe style has racked up dozens of five-star ratings, with shoppers saying they’re “very pleasantly surprised with how comfortable” the flats are, and “the finish is like a high-end brand.”

Aerosoles Perry Mary Jane Flats

$99$67 at Amazon

Equal parts comfortable and chic, these Mary Jane flats are designed in shiny patent leather with cushy foam insoles, non-slip rubber outsoles, and statement buckle details. They come in sizes 5–12, and they’re also available inblackandgold.

Dream Pairs Mary Jane Ballet Flats

$50$27 at Amazon

A classic round toe, adjustable ankle strap, and subtle matte finish lend elegance to these silver Mary Jane flats in soft faux leather.One customer, who received the flats for free, said they wore them for “over eight hours with no pain or discomfort,” and they “can be dressed up or down.”

Sam Edelman Michaela Mary Jane Flats

$130 at Amazon

The timeless Mary Jane silhouette gets a bold update with a wider strap, contrasting gold buckle detail, and shining silver leather finish. In addition to silver, these statement-making Mary Janes come in a whopping 39 colors, patterns, and textures, includingblack and white tweed,dark blue denim, andleopard print faux calf hair.

Dolce Vita Reyes Ballet Flats

$118 at Amazon

AprCoco Mary Jane Flats

$46$38 at Amazon

If you love the silver Mary Janes that Fonda wore on the red carpet, try this pair, which is designed in the same glossy patent with a subtly rounded toe. The flats also come inblack patent,red satin, andmatte black, and sizes 6–11.

Naturalizer Maxwell Mary Jane Ballet Flats

$99 at Amazon

These Mary Jane flats have a round toe and wider strap with a hook-and-loop closure. They’re designed with the brand’s comfortable Contour+ technology and non-slip outsoles, making them perfect for fall activities like apple picking and strolling through pumpkin patches.

Riekhany Bow Mary Jane Flats

$59 at Amazon

Try a totally different take on the Mary Jane trend with these flats, which feature a tied bow detail across the vamp and a dramatic, square-toe silhouette. They come in seven additional colors and sizes 5–12;one happy shoppersaid they’re “very comfortable, and they look very expensive.”

Coach Emilia Mary Jane Ballet Flats

$175$105 at Amazon

These Mary Janes are a delicate, graceful addition to your fall closet, thanks to a timeless ballet flat silhouette with a black elastic band strap and low stacked heel. They also come inblack,cream, andchocolate brown, and sizes 5–11.

See More from PEOPLE ShoppingPetite Shoppers Don’t Have to Hem These $16 Walmart Lounge Pants, and They’re Selling Out FastMartha Stewart’s Modern Farmhouse Furniture and Decor Is on Sale from $22 Just in Time for a Spring RefreshThis $27 Nylon Tote Bag ‘Holds So Much’ — Even a Change of Clothes and Shoes

See More from PEOPLE Shopping

Petite Shoppers Don’t Have to Hem These $16 Walmart Lounge Pants, and They’re Selling Out FastMartha Stewart’s Modern Farmhouse Furniture and Decor Is on Sale from $22 Just in Time for a Spring RefreshThis $27 Nylon Tote Bag ‘Holds So Much’ — Even a Change of Clothes and Shoes

Petite Shoppers Don’t Have to Hem These $16 Walmart Lounge Pants, and They’re Selling Out Fast

Martha Stewart’s Modern Farmhouse Furniture and Decor Is on Sale from $22 Just in Time for a Spring Refresh

This $27 Nylon Tote Bag ‘Holds So Much’ — Even a Change of Clothes and Shoes

source: people.com