Lindsay Lohan and Lacey Chabert Reprise TheirMean GirlsRoles onWWHL— with Andy Cohen as Regina George

Mar. 15, 2025

From L: Lindsay Lohan and Lacey Chabert onWatch What Happens Live with Andy CohenNov. 20, 2024, and inMean Girls(2004).Photo:Bravo; Courtesy of Paramount Home Entertainment

Bravo; Courtesy of Paramount Home Entertainment

On Wednesdays,Lindsay LohanandLacey Chabertwear pink — at least, metaphorically!

This past Wednesday, Nov. 20, the two actresses joinedAndy CohenonWatch What Happens Live, where they reprised their roles from their iconic teen comedyMean Girls.

After Cohen, 56, stormed off with a “Whatever, I’m getting cheese fries,” his wig flowing behind him, Chabert and Lohan couldn’t help but descend into giggles before continuing the scene.

“Ex-boyfriends are off limits to friends — that’s just, like, the rules of feminism!” Chabert said without missing a beat as they concluded the reenactment.

Never miss a story — sign up forPEOPLE’s free daily newsletterto stay up-to-date on the best of what PEOPLE has to offer​​, from celebrity news to compelling human-interest stories.

In anothersegment of the episode, Cohen asked Lohan about popular roles she has auditioned for but didn’t get, to which she replied that she “[hasn’t] auditioned” sinceThe Parent Trap.

She also confirmed thatMichael Eisner, who was CEO of the Walt Disney Company at the time, asked her at the 1998 premiere of the movie, “Where’s your twin?!”

“I was so young I don’t even know how I thought to say this, but I’ll never forget what I said: I said, ‘Well you should’ve paid me double, ‘cause I don’t have one!’ " Lohan recalled.

Chabert and Lohan both have new Netflix holiday rom-com projects they’re promoting. For Lohan, it’sOur Little Secret, and for Chabert, it’sHot Frosty.

And thoughMean Girlspremiered more than 20 years ago, the movie hasn’t strayed far from the stars’ minds. Last year, Lohan, Chabert andAmanda Seyfried, who rounded out the Plastics clique as Karen Smith in the original movie, reprised their characters for aWalmart Black Friday ad.

The PEOPLE Puzzler crossword is here! How quickly can you solve it? Play now!

Lacey Chabert (left), Rachel McAdams, Lindsay Lohan and Amanda Seyfried in ‘Mean Girls’.Michael Gibson/Paramount/Kobal/Shutterstock

Michael Gibson/Paramount/Kobal/Shutterstock

Lohan also had amemorable surprise cameoin theMean Girlsmovie musicalthat was released early this year, as moderator of the pivotal Mathletes tournament oppositeAngourie Riceas Cady.

On Nov. 14, Lohan and Chabert had anotherminiMean Girlsreunion, as the Freaky Friday star shared a cute photo of the pair on her Instagram Stories.

Referencing one of Gretchen’s iconic quotes from the movie in her post, Lohan added the comment, “So Fetch catching up with my girl@thereallacey,” alongside a wink, happy face and pink heart emoji, as well as a ChristmasMean GirlsGIF.

source: people.com