Mayci Neeley Gets a Shocking 'Sinner Sunday Confession,' Is Conflicted When She Realizes It's About Taylor Frankie Paul's Boyfriend

Mar. 15, 2025

Mayci and Taylor (left), Dakota and Taylor.Photo:Mayci Neeley/TikTok; Taylor Frankie Paul/TikTok

Mayci Neeley/TikTok; Taylor Frankie Paul/TikTok

Warning: This post contains spoilers for Hulu’sThe Secret Lives of Mormon Wives.

Mayci Neeleyfound herself in a bad spot when information she didn’t want to know fell into her lap.

The Secret Lives of Mormon Wivesstar saw a Sinner Sunday go wrong when she received a confession she wasn’t expecting.

As castmateTaylor Frankie Pauldetailed her argument with boyfriend Dakota Mortensen on the way to the cast’s trip to Las Vegas, Mayci revealed in a confessional that she had “a secret that I’ve been holding in for a little bit.”

“As Taylor was telling her story of her and Dakota fighting, at this point I have to tell somebody or I’m going to die inside,” she told producers.

Mayci went on to explain her Sinner Sunday tradition and how it came to be. “Sinner Sunday was something I came up with when I was bored one day. I wanted people to confess their sins, and what better day to do it than Sunday? So it became a little thing where every week, I would post, and people could anonymously confess their sins. And so that’s when I got the confession about Dakota.”

Never miss a story — sign up forPEOPLE’s free daily newsletterto stay up-to-date on the best of what PEOPLE has to offer​​, from celebrity news to compelling human interest stories.

Sinner Sunday confession about Dakota.Hulu

Hulu

Later, Mayci tellsMikayla MatthewsandDemi Engemannabout the secret confessed to her.

“It says, ‘I accidentally slept with Dakota before I knew him and Taylor were together. I only met Taylor once and I’m terrified to tell her but I know she has a right to know… HELP.'”

Mayci explains that she suspects it may be a woman named Jenna, who Taylor knows of. While it seemed there may have been some overlap in the relationships, he vowed to Taylor that he hadn’t had anything to do with her or anyone else since they made things official.

Later, while the women are out together, Mayci comes clean to Taylor. She’s honest about being conflicted, considering how close Taylor was to her due date at the time.

“I feel like if it were me, I’d want to know and I feel like you’d probably want to know the more I think about it.”

Later, at Taylor’s instruction, Mayci follows up with Jenna to find out if it was her and what’s really going on. The juicy series leaves us on a cliffhanger, looking to find out if Dakota was telling the truth.

The Secret Lives of Mormon Wivesis currently streaming on Hulu.

source: people.com