The 17 Best Self-Tanners, Tested by Real People

Mar. 15, 2025

In This ArticleView AllIn This ArticleOur Top PicksReviewsAdd to CartOthers We TriedWhat to KnowBehind The ScenesFAQWhy Trust PEOPLE?What Is PEOPLE Tested?

In This ArticleView All

In This Article

View All

Our Top Picks

Reviews

Add to Cart

Others We Tried

What to Know

Behind The Scenes

FAQ

Why Trust PEOPLE?

What Is PEOPLE Tested?

Photo:People / Sophia DeVito

People / Sophia DeVito

Sun damage is out, and UV protection is in. From cosmetic effects like fine lines, wrinkles, and dark spots to health concerns like melanoma, it’s best to avoid sun exposure. But practicing sun safety withhigh-quality sunscreenshouldn’t mean giving up your sunkissed glow.

Experts Say“Self-tanner is a great way to obtain a sun-kissed glow without damaging your skin from UV exposure, [and] there are many safe, healthy, and natural-looking self-tanners available.” —Dr. Dendy Engelman, board-certified cosmetic dermatologist

Experts Say

“Self-tanner is a great way to obtain a sun-kissed glow without damaging your skin from UV exposure, [and] there are many safe, healthy, and natural-looking self-tanners available.” —Dr. Dendy Engelman, board-certified cosmetic dermatologist

We tested 43 of the most popular self-tanners to find the formulas that would give you the most natural summer glow. These are our 17 favorites, including top picks from St. Tropez, Bondi Sands, and Coco and Eve.

Best Overall:Bondi Sands Pure Self Tanning Drops at Bondisands.euJump to Review

Best Overall:Bondi Sands Pure Self Tanning Drops at Bondisands.eu

Best Overall:

Best Overall (Cheaper):

SALE

Best Value:L’Oréal Sublime Bronze Self-Tanning Water Mist at Amazon$7Jump to Review

Best Value:L’Oréal Sublime Bronze Self-Tanning Water Mist at Amazon$7

Best Value:

Best for Beginners:Isle of Paradise Express 30-Min Mousse at Amazon$32Jump to Review

Best for Beginners:Isle of Paradise Express 30-Min Mousse at Amazon$32

Best for Beginners:

Best Mousse:St. Tropez Self Tan Classic Bronzing Mousse at Amazon$44Jump to Review

Best Mousse:St. Tropez Self Tan Classic Bronzing Mousse at Amazon$44

Best Mousse:

Best Foam:Coco & Eve Sunny Honey Bali Bronzing Foam at Amazon$38Jump to Review

Best Foam:Coco & Eve Sunny Honey Bali Bronzing Foam at Amazon$38

Best Foam:

Best for Fair Skin:Loving Tan 2 HR Self Tanning Mousse at Amazon$36Jump to Review

Best for Fair Skin:Loving Tan 2 HR Self Tanning Mousse at Amazon$36

Best for Fair Skin:

Best for Deep Skin:Bondi Sands Self Tanning Foam at Amazon$29Jump to Review

Best for Deep Skin:Bondi Sands Self Tanning Foam at Amazon$29

Best for Deep Skin:

Best for Face:St. Tropez Self Tan Purity Face Mist at Amazon$33Jump to Review

Best for Face:St. Tropez Self Tan Purity Face Mist at Amazon$33

Best for Face:

Best Subtle Tan:

Best OverallBondi Sands Pure Self Tanning DropsPHOTO: AmazonView on Bondisands.eu

Best OverallBondi Sands Pure Self Tanning Drops

Best Overall

Bondi Sands Pure Self Tanning Drops

PHOTO: Amazon

View on Bondisands.eu

Star QualitiesBuildable depending on amount you applyDoesn’t transfer onto sheets or clothingWorks quickly, so you can see results within a dayRed FlagsRequires a mixed-in moisturizer to apply

Star QualitiesBuildable depending on amount you applyDoesn’t transfer onto sheets or clothingWorks quickly, so you can see results within a day

Buildable depending on amount you apply

Doesn’t transfer onto sheets or clothing

Works quickly, so you can see results within a day

Red FlagsRequires a mixed-in moisturizer to apply

Requires a mixed-in moisturizer to apply

While you do need to mix the self-tanner with a moisturizer to apply, we found it was easier to apply than others we tried. Plus, adding moisturizer hydrates the skin and helps support a faux glow. Once applied, you don’t have to worry about this tanner transferring to your sheets or clothes since the drop formula doesn’t budge.

Size:1.35 ounces |Shades:Dark |Key Ingredients:Hyaluronic acid, vitamin C, vitamin E

Best Overall (Cheaper)

$14$10 at AmazonView on Mykaoshop.com

Star QualitiesStreak-free and easy to blendDoesn’t transfer onto sheets or clothesGives an instant glowRed FlagsNo applicator mitt includedLight fragrance might bother some

Star QualitiesStreak-free and easy to blendDoesn’t transfer onto sheets or clothesGives an instant glow

Streak-free and easy to blend

Doesn’t transfer onto sheets or clothes

Gives an instant glow

Red FlagsNo applicator mitt includedLight fragrance might bother some

No applicator mitt included

Light fragrance might bother some

Size:5 ounces |Shades:Medium, deep |Key Ingredients:N/A

PHOTO: People / Chelsea DintermanPHOTO: People / Chelsea Dinterman

Best ValueL’Oréal Sublime Bronze Self-Tanning Water MistPHOTO: L’Oreal Paris USA$7 at Amazon$13 at Walmart$15 at Riteaid.comStar QualitiesFormula sprays on easily without streaksDoesn’t transfer onto handsRed FlagsSpray formula may be tricky for beginnersThis L’Oreal tanning mist leads the pack in drugstore self-tanners. It sprays evenly onto the skin without any streaks, though the spray application may be tricky for beginners. We were impressed with the glow it gave in just one application and that it didn’t transfer onto our hands.Size:3 ounces |Shades:One shade |Key Ingredients:Vitamin EPeople / Adam Groffman

Best ValueL’Oréal Sublime Bronze Self-Tanning Water MistPHOTO: L’Oreal Paris USA$7 at Amazon$13 at Walmart$15 at Riteaid.com

Best ValueL’Oréal Sublime Bronze Self-Tanning Water Mist

Best Value

L’Oréal Sublime Bronze Self-Tanning Water Mist

PHOTO: L’Oreal Paris USA

$7 at Amazon$13 at Walmart$15 at Riteaid.com

Star QualitiesFormula sprays on easily without streaksDoesn’t transfer onto handsRed FlagsSpray formula may be tricky for beginners

Star QualitiesFormula sprays on easily without streaksDoesn’t transfer onto hands

Formula sprays on easily without streaks

Doesn’t transfer onto hands

Red FlagsSpray formula may be tricky for beginners

Spray formula may be tricky for beginners

This L’Oreal tanning mist leads the pack in drugstore self-tanners. It sprays evenly onto the skin without any streaks, though the spray application may be tricky for beginners. We were impressed with the glow it gave in just one application and that it didn’t transfer onto our hands.

Size:3 ounces |Shades:One shade |Key Ingredients:Vitamin E

People / Adam Groffman

Best for BeginnersIsle of Paradise Express 30-Min MoussePHOTO: The Isle of Paradise$32 at Amazon$34 at SephoraView on Theisleofparadise.comStar QualitiesEasy to apply and blendDries quicklyRed FlagsTakes around two hours to tanNo applicator mitt includedThe mousse texture of this self-tanner makes it super easy to apply and blend with the handy reusable mitt (sold separately) for an even, salon-worthy glow-up. The formula also dried incredibly fast (within 30 seconds), which made the curing process a lot more comfortable and prevented streaks from occurring. Although the formula says it’s a 30-minute express self-tanner, we found that it takes a couple of hours to notice a faux glow, which is still fast compared to other formulas we tried.Size:6.7 ounces |Shades:One buildable shade |Key Ingredients:Hyaluronic acid, glycerin, vitamin CPeople / Jessica Comstock

Best for BeginnersIsle of Paradise Express 30-Min MoussePHOTO: The Isle of Paradise$32 at Amazon$34 at SephoraView on Theisleofparadise.com

Best for BeginnersIsle of Paradise Express 30-Min Mousse

Best for Beginners

Isle of Paradise Express 30-Min Mousse

PHOTO: The Isle of Paradise

$32 at Amazon$34 at SephoraView on Theisleofparadise.com

Star QualitiesEasy to apply and blendDries quicklyRed FlagsTakes around two hours to tanNo applicator mitt included

Star QualitiesEasy to apply and blendDries quickly

Easy to apply and blend

Dries quickly

Red FlagsTakes around two hours to tanNo applicator mitt included

Takes around two hours to tan

The mousse texture of this self-tanner makes it super easy to apply and blend with the handy reusable mitt (sold separately) for an even, salon-worthy glow-up. The formula also dried incredibly fast (within 30 seconds), which made the curing process a lot more comfortable and prevented streaks from occurring. Although the formula says it’s a 30-minute express self-tanner, we found that it takes a couple of hours to notice a faux glow, which is still fast compared to other formulas we tried.

Size:6.7 ounces |Shades:One buildable shade |Key Ingredients:Hyaluronic acid, glycerin, vitamin C

People / Jessica Comstock

Best MousseSt. Tropez Self Tan Classic Bronzing MoussePHOTO: Amazon$44 at Amazon$44$18 at Nordstrom$34 at Sephora

Best MousseSt. Tropez Self Tan Classic Bronzing Mousse

Best Mousse

St. Tropez Self Tan Classic Bronzing Mousse

$44 at Amazon$44$18 at Nordstrom$34 at Sephora

Star QualitiesBlendable formula dries quickly with no streaksDoesn’t transfer — even on white sheetsDoesn’t smell like a self-tannerRed FlagsNo applicator mitt included

Star QualitiesBlendable formula dries quickly with no streaksDoesn’t transfer — even on white sheetsDoesn’t smell like a self-tanner

Blendable formula dries quickly with no streaks

Doesn’t transfer — even on white sheets

Doesn’t smell like a self-tanner

Red FlagsNo applicator mitt included

Size:4, 8 ounces |Shades:One shade |Key Ingredients:100 percent natural DHA

People / Kristen Geil

Best FoamCoco & Eve Sunny Honey Bali Bronzing FoamPHOTO: Coco & Eve$38 at Amazon$38 at Ulta$38 at Revolve

Best FoamCoco & Eve Sunny Honey Bali Bronzing Foam

Best Foam

Coco & Eve Sunny Honey Bali Bronzing Foam

PHOTO: Coco & Eve

$38 at Amazon$38 at Ulta$38 at Revolve

Star QualitiesGreen-gray base keeps orange tones at bayDoesn’t transfer onto sheets, towels, or clothingEasy to blendLotus extract firms the skin and targets celluliteRed FlagsWe couldn’t find any

Star QualitiesGreen-gray base keeps orange tones at bayDoesn’t transfer onto sheets, towels, or clothingEasy to blendLotus extract firms the skin and targets cellulite

Green-gray base keeps orange tones at bay

Doesn’t transfer onto sheets, towels, or clothing

Easy to blend

Lotus extract firms the skin and targets cellulite

Red FlagsWe couldn’t find any

We couldn’t find any

Size:6.7 ounces |Shades:Medium, dark, ultra-dark |Key Ingredients:Natural DHA, lotus extract, raw virgin coconut, mango, fig, cocoa

People / Ashley Schaubroeck

Best for Fair SkinLoving Tan 2 HR Self Tanning MoussePHOTO: Amazon$36 at Amazon$65$42 at Nordstrom$40 at Ulta

Best for Fair SkinLoving Tan 2 HR Self Tanning Mousse

Best for Fair Skin

Loving Tan 2 HR Self Tanning Mousse

$36 at Amazon$65$42 at Nordstrom$40 at Ulta

Star QualitiesIncluded mitt makes it easy to achieve an even tanResults looked natural, even on fair skinRed FlagsTan briefly looks orange before fading to a natural-looking tanSticky upon immediate application but dries quickly

Star QualitiesIncluded mitt makes it easy to achieve an even tanResults looked natural, even on fair skin

Included mitt makes it easy to achieve an even tan

Results looked natural, even on fair skin

Red FlagsTan briefly looks orange before fading to a natural-looking tanSticky upon immediate application but dries quickly

Tan briefly looks orange before fading to a natural-looking tan

Sticky upon immediate application but dries quickly

Size:4, 6.7 ounces |Shades:Medium, dark, ultra-dark |Key Ingredients:Naturally derived DHA, aloe vera

People / Hilary Braaksma

Best for Deep SkinBondi Sands Self Tanning Foam$29 at Amazon$25 at Target$38$17 at WalmartStar QualitiesOffers an “ultra dark” shade recommended for deeper skin tonesGives a healthy glow that fades evenly over timeRed FlagsStrong smell that may bother someTransfers onto sheets and clothingIf you’re looking to give your melanated skin a sunkissed glow, try out the Bondi Sands tanning foam. Whereas most self-tanners don’t provide a sufficient shade range to bronze deeper skin tones, the ultra-dark shade of this tanner is recommended for melanated skin. Asone Amazon reviewer put it, “Black girls can self-tan, too!”The application process is tricky since it dries quickly and tends to get streaky. We recommend doing extensive prep work (like exfoliating and moisturizing) to get the most even tan. It has a strong smell and transfers onto clothing and sheets, but we thought the glowing result was worth the effort.Size:3.3, 6.7 ounces |Shades:Light/medium, dark, ultra dark |Key Ingredients:Aloe vera

Best for Deep SkinBondi Sands Self Tanning Foam$29 at Amazon$25 at Target$38$17 at Walmart

Best for Deep SkinBondi Sands Self Tanning Foam

Best for Deep Skin

Bondi Sands Self Tanning Foam

$29 at Amazon$25 at Target$38$17 at Walmart

Star QualitiesOffers an “ultra dark” shade recommended for deeper skin tonesGives a healthy glow that fades evenly over timeRed FlagsStrong smell that may bother someTransfers onto sheets and clothing

Star QualitiesOffers an “ultra dark” shade recommended for deeper skin tonesGives a healthy glow that fades evenly over time

Offers an “ultra dark” shade recommended for deeper skin tones

Gives a healthy glow that fades evenly over time

Red FlagsStrong smell that may bother someTransfers onto sheets and clothing

Strong smell that may bother some

Transfers onto sheets and clothing

If you’re looking to give your melanated skin a sunkissed glow, try out the Bondi Sands tanning foam. Whereas most self-tanners don’t provide a sufficient shade range to bronze deeper skin tones, the ultra-dark shade of this tanner is recommended for melanated skin. Asone Amazon reviewer put it, “Black girls can self-tan, too!”

The application process is tricky since it dries quickly and tends to get streaky. We recommend doing extensive prep work (like exfoliating and moisturizing) to get the most even tan. It has a strong smell and transfers onto clothing and sheets, but we thought the glowing result was worth the effort.

Size:3.3, 6.7 ounces |Shades:Light/medium, dark, ultra dark |Key Ingredients:Aloe vera

Best for FaceSt. Tropez Self Tan Purity Face MistPHOTO: Amazon$33 at Amazon$33 at Nordstrom$33 at SephoraStar QualitiesClear formula doesn’t transfer onto clothesSpray is easy to apply for even coverageIncludes refreshing and hydrating skincare ingredientsRed FlagsRequires a few uses to see a noticeable glowWhen putting self-tanner on your face, you want a formula that’s easy to apply and provides an even finish. This buildable self-tanning spray goes on clear, doesn’t transfer onto clothes, sheets, or towels, and is easy to achieve even coverage. It also features lots of refreshing skincare ingredients that hydrate and nourish the skin, including moisture-attracting hyaluronic acid, green mandarin water, and hibiscus extract. Since this is a buildable formula, we didn’t notice a difference right away. However, with several uses, we built up a nice glow that looked natural.Size:2.7 ounces |Shades:Light to medium |Key Ingredients:Hyaluronic acid, green mandarin water, hibiscus extractPeople / Elizabeth Rhodes

Best for FaceSt. Tropez Self Tan Purity Face MistPHOTO: Amazon$33 at Amazon$33 at Nordstrom$33 at Sephora

Best for FaceSt. Tropez Self Tan Purity Face Mist

Best for Face

St. Tropez Self Tan Purity Face Mist

$33 at Amazon$33 at Nordstrom$33 at Sephora

Star QualitiesClear formula doesn’t transfer onto clothesSpray is easy to apply for even coverageIncludes refreshing and hydrating skincare ingredientsRed FlagsRequires a few uses to see a noticeable glow

Star QualitiesClear formula doesn’t transfer onto clothesSpray is easy to apply for even coverageIncludes refreshing and hydrating skincare ingredients

Clear formula doesn’t transfer onto clothes

Spray is easy to apply for even coverage

Includes refreshing and hydrating skincare ingredients

Red FlagsRequires a few uses to see a noticeable glow

Requires a few uses to see a noticeable glow

When putting self-tanner on your face, you want a formula that’s easy to apply and provides an even finish. This buildable self-tanning spray goes on clear, doesn’t transfer onto clothes, sheets, or towels, and is easy to achieve even coverage. It also features lots of refreshing skincare ingredients that hydrate and nourish the skin, including moisture-attracting hyaluronic acid, green mandarin water, and hibiscus extract. Since this is a buildable formula, we didn’t notice a difference right away. However, with several uses, we built up a nice glow that looked natural.

Size:2.7 ounces |Shades:Light to medium |Key Ingredients:Hyaluronic acid, green mandarin water, hibiscus extract

People / Elizabeth Rhodes

Best Subtle Tan

$38 at Amazon$21 at Target$15 at Walmart

Star QualitiesProvides a light, subtle glowDoesn’t transfer onto clothing or beddingPerfect for the face and bodyTan lasts over a weekRed FlagsOnly one shade

Star QualitiesProvides a light, subtle glowDoesn’t transfer onto clothing or beddingPerfect for the face and bodyTan lasts over a week

Provides a light, subtle glow

Doesn’t transfer onto clothing or bedding

Perfect for the face and body

Tan lasts over a week

Red FlagsOnly one shade

Only one shade

In addition to subtleness, the drops don’t transfer easily, so you don’t have to worry about ruining sheets or clothes, and if you use them several days in a row, the tanning formula will stay put on your complexion for over a week. Although the self-tanning drops don’t come in different shades, we love that you can build and add more drops for a deeper and more custom tan.

Size:1 ounce |Shades:One buildable shade |Key Ingredients:Erythrulose

Best Long-LastingIL Makiage 85/66 Sun FoamPHOTO: IL Makiage$65 at AmazonView on Ilmakiage.comStar QualitiesLasts for a full weekComes with a brush and velvet mitt for easy applicationTan develops almost immediatelyRed FlagsPricier than others on this listThe Il Makiage foam tanner is designed to last and never get blotchy as it fades, so you will have an even, subtle tan for a week (or longer). It’s easy to apply with the included velvet mitt and applicator brush, has a blendable yet dry texture that doesn’t transfer, and you don’t need a lot of product to achieve a gorgeous glow. The development process is also almost immediate, so it can give you a quick dose of color in a pinch. While it’s pricier than others on this list, keep in mind that the cost includes application tools.Size:4 ounces |Shades:One shade |Key Ingredients:Erythrulose, hyaluronic acid, aloe veraPeople / Taylor Calta

Best Long-LastingIL Makiage 85/66 Sun FoamPHOTO: IL Makiage$65 at AmazonView on Ilmakiage.com

Best Long-LastingIL Makiage 85/66 Sun Foam

Best Long-Lasting

IL Makiage 85/66 Sun Foam

PHOTO: IL Makiage

$65 at AmazonView on Ilmakiage.com

Star QualitiesLasts for a full weekComes with a brush and velvet mitt for easy applicationTan develops almost immediatelyRed FlagsPricier than others on this list

Star QualitiesLasts for a full weekComes with a brush and velvet mitt for easy applicationTan develops almost immediately

Lasts for a full week

Comes with a brush and velvet mitt for easy application

Tan develops almost immediately

Red FlagsPricier than others on this list

Pricier than others on this list

The Il Makiage foam tanner is designed to last and never get blotchy as it fades, so you will have an even, subtle tan for a week (or longer). It’s easy to apply with the included velvet mitt and applicator brush, has a blendable yet dry texture that doesn’t transfer, and you don’t need a lot of product to achieve a gorgeous glow. The development process is also almost immediate, so it can give you a quick dose of color in a pinch. While it’s pricier than others on this list, keep in mind that the cost includes application tools.

Size:4 ounces |Shades:One shade |Key Ingredients:Erythrulose, hyaluronic acid, aloe vera

People / Taylor Calta

Best Fragrance-FreeTanologist Self Tan Mousse$18 at Amazon$18 at Target$20 at UltaStar QualitiesFormulated for sensitive skin typesComes in four different shadesHydrates skin thanks to skincare ingredients like hyaluronic acidRed FlagsNo included mittWhether you have sensitive skin or can’t stand the smell of self-tanner, the fragrance-free Tanologist Self-Tan Mousse is worth trying. The formula is designed with sensitive skin types in mind and includes hyaluronic acid, vitamin C, and aloe vera to nourish and hydrate the skin. We love how easy it is to achieve an even tan (especially when using a tanning mitt, which is not included). It also offers the largest shade range on this list, so you can get a more accurate tan for your skin tone.Size:6.76 ounces |Shades:Light, medium, dark, extra dark |Key Ingredients:Hyaluronic acid, vitamin C, aloe veraPeople / Emma Rose Connolly

Best Fragrance-FreeTanologist Self Tan Mousse$18 at Amazon$18 at Target$20 at Ulta

Best Fragrance-FreeTanologist Self Tan Mousse

Best Fragrance-Free

Tanologist Self Tan Mousse

$18 at Amazon$18 at Target$20 at Ulta

Star QualitiesFormulated for sensitive skin typesComes in four different shadesHydrates skin thanks to skincare ingredients like hyaluronic acidRed FlagsNo included mitt

Star QualitiesFormulated for sensitive skin typesComes in four different shadesHydrates skin thanks to skincare ingredients like hyaluronic acid

Formulated for sensitive skin types

Comes in four different shades

Hydrates skin thanks to skincare ingredients like hyaluronic acid

Red FlagsNo included mitt

No included mitt

Whether you have sensitive skin or can’t stand the smell of self-tanner, the fragrance-free Tanologist Self-Tan Mousse is worth trying. The formula is designed with sensitive skin types in mind and includes hyaluronic acid, vitamin C, and aloe vera to nourish and hydrate the skin. We love how easy it is to achieve an even tan (especially when using a tanning mitt, which is not included). It also offers the largest shade range on this list, so you can get a more accurate tan for your skin tone.

Size:6.76 ounces |Shades:Light, medium, dark, extra dark |Key Ingredients:Hyaluronic acid, vitamin C, aloe vera

People / Emma Rose Connolly

Best ToweletteTan Towel Body Tan TowelettesPHOTO: Macy’s$35 at Amazon$35 at Macy’sView on Shopbop.comStar QualitiesAvailable in full-body and half-body sizes for on-the-go touch-upsLasts for up to seven daysEasy to use, even for self-tan beginnersRed FlagsSticky upon application but dries quicklyTanning towelettes are a convenient, travel-friendly option for adding a sun-kissed touch on the go. The Tan Towel Body Tan Towelettes are so fool-proof that even beginners can achieve an even, all-over tan. After the initial application, the tan can last up to seven days, making it one of the longest-lasting tans on our list. Albeit a little sticky at first, we found that the stickiness allowed us to see where the solution was applied for an even application. And, after a few minutes, it completely dried up, so it wasn’t an issue.Size:5-pack |Shades:Classic, plus, dark |Key Ingredients:Erythrulose

Best ToweletteTan Towel Body Tan TowelettesPHOTO: Macy’s$35 at Amazon$35 at Macy’sView on Shopbop.com

Best ToweletteTan Towel Body Tan Towelettes

Best Towelette

Tan Towel Body Tan Towelettes

PHOTO: Macy’s

$35 at Amazon$35 at Macy’sView on Shopbop.com

Star QualitiesAvailable in full-body and half-body sizes for on-the-go touch-upsLasts for up to seven daysEasy to use, even for self-tan beginnersRed FlagsSticky upon application but dries quickly

Star QualitiesAvailable in full-body and half-body sizes for on-the-go touch-upsLasts for up to seven daysEasy to use, even for self-tan beginners

Available in full-body and half-body sizes for on-the-go touch-ups

Lasts for up to seven days

Easy to use, even for self-tan beginners

Red FlagsSticky upon application but dries quickly

Sticky upon application but dries quickly

Tanning towelettes are a convenient, travel-friendly option for adding a sun-kissed touch on the go. The Tan Towel Body Tan Towelettes are so fool-proof that even beginners can achieve an even, all-over tan. After the initial application, the tan can last up to seven days, making it one of the longest-lasting tans on our list. Albeit a little sticky at first, we found that the stickiness allowed us to see where the solution was applied for an even application. And, after a few minutes, it completely dried up, so it wasn’t an issue.

Size:5-pack |Shades:Classic, plus, dark |Key Ingredients:Erythrulose

Best Gelb.Tan Glow Your Own Way Tan GelPHOTO: Ulta$17$12 at Amazon$13 at Target$13 at WalmartStar QualitiesThick consistency made it easy to applyFormulated with hyaluronic acid and vitamin C to nourish the skinDoesn’t transfer onto clothes or sheetsRed FlagsTakes 15 to 30 minutes to dryIf you prefer a self-tanner with a gel consistency, try the b.Tan Glow Your Own Way Tan Gel. This product has a thick consistency that applies evenly without streaks or blotchiness. Plus, its formula features hyaluronic acid and vitamin C for their skin-plumping benefits. We had no problems with the gel transferring onto our sheets, towels, or clothes. Although it did take some time for the self-tanner gel to dry on our skin, we loved how it gave way to a natural-looking finish.Size:16 ounces |Shades:One shade |Key Ingredients:Hyaluronic acid, vitamin CPHOTO: People / Connie KelehanPHOTO: People / Connie Kelehan

Best Gelb.Tan Glow Your Own Way Tan GelPHOTO: Ulta$17$12 at Amazon$13 at Target$13 at Walmart

Best Gelb.Tan Glow Your Own Way Tan Gel

Best Gel

b.Tan Glow Your Own Way Tan Gel

PHOTO: Ulta

$17$12 at Amazon$13 at Target$13 at Walmart

Star QualitiesThick consistency made it easy to applyFormulated with hyaluronic acid and vitamin C to nourish the skinDoesn’t transfer onto clothes or sheetsRed FlagsTakes 15 to 30 minutes to dry

Star QualitiesThick consistency made it easy to applyFormulated with hyaluronic acid and vitamin C to nourish the skinDoesn’t transfer onto clothes or sheets

Thick consistency made it easy to apply

Formulated with hyaluronic acid and vitamin C to nourish the skin

Doesn’t transfer onto clothes or sheets

Red FlagsTakes 15 to 30 minutes to dry

Takes 15 to 30 minutes to dry

If you prefer a self-tanner with a gel consistency, try the b.Tan Glow Your Own Way Tan Gel. This product has a thick consistency that applies evenly without streaks or blotchiness. Plus, its formula features hyaluronic acid and vitamin C for their skin-plumping benefits. We had no problems with the gel transferring onto our sheets, towels, or clothes. Although it did take some time for the self-tanner gel to dry on our skin, we loved how it gave way to a natural-looking finish.

Size:16 ounces |Shades:One shade |Key Ingredients:Hyaluronic acid, vitamin C

PHOTO: People / Connie KelehanPHOTO: People / Connie Kelehan

Best ExfoliatingDr. Dennis Gross Skincare Alpha Beta Glow Pad Intense GlowPHOTO: Dr. Dennis Gross$39 at Amazon$39 at Nordstrom$40 at DermstoreStar QualitiesAHAs and BHAs exfoliate the skinActive vitamin D gives a sun-kissed glowDries in one minuteRed FlagsWipe might irritate some skin typesThe Dr. Dennis Gross Alpha Beta Glow Pad Intense Glow for Face is part self-tanner, part peel pad, thanks to its inclusion of AHAs and BHAs, which exfoliate the complexion with one swipe. The wipes also feature active vitamin D to add a gorgeous glow to your complexion. These wipes are easy to apply, buildable, and dry in just one minute. The rough texture of the pad feels a little like a peel pad, which some might find irritating. Bonus: These wipes are convenient to carry and pack on trips.Size:20-pack |Shades:One shade |Key Ingredients:AHAs, BHAs, active vitamin D

Best ExfoliatingDr. Dennis Gross Skincare Alpha Beta Glow Pad Intense GlowPHOTO: Dr. Dennis Gross$39 at Amazon$39 at Nordstrom$40 at Dermstore

Best ExfoliatingDr. Dennis Gross Skincare Alpha Beta Glow Pad Intense Glow

Best Exfoliating

Dr. Dennis Gross Skincare Alpha Beta Glow Pad Intense Glow

PHOTO: Dr. Dennis Gross

$39 at Amazon$39 at Nordstrom$40 at Dermstore

Star QualitiesAHAs and BHAs exfoliate the skinActive vitamin D gives a sun-kissed glowDries in one minuteRed FlagsWipe might irritate some skin types

Star QualitiesAHAs and BHAs exfoliate the skinActive vitamin D gives a sun-kissed glowDries in one minute

AHAs and BHAs exfoliate the skin

Active vitamin D gives a sun-kissed glow

Dries in one minute

Red FlagsWipe might irritate some skin types

Wipe might irritate some skin types

The Dr. Dennis Gross Alpha Beta Glow Pad Intense Glow for Face is part self-tanner, part peel pad, thanks to its inclusion of AHAs and BHAs, which exfoliate the complexion with one swipe. The wipes also feature active vitamin D to add a gorgeous glow to your complexion. These wipes are easy to apply, buildable, and dry in just one minute. The rough texture of the pad feels a little like a peel pad, which some might find irritating. Bonus: These wipes are convenient to carry and pack on trips.

Size:20-pack |Shades:One shade |Key Ingredients:AHAs, BHAs, active vitamin D

Best SerumTypology Self-Tanning SerumPHOTO: TypologyView on Typology.comStar QualitiesGlides easily onto skinLasts up to seven daysDoesn’t transfer onto clothing, towels, or sheetsCan be used alone or blended with moisturizerRed FlagsExpensive for a one-ounce bottleWe loved the longevity and easy application of the Typology self-tanning serum. Since it has an oily texture, it applies smoothly to the skin for a deeper tan or mixes well with moisturizer for a more subtle glow. We found that it kept its integrity for seven days (and even once it started to fade, it still looked good). Despite having an oily texture, it absorbs quickly into the complexion and doesn’t transfer onto clothing or sheets. While it’s on the pricey side, the unique application and long-term results make this a worthwhile pick.Size:1 ounce |Shades:One shade |Key Ingredients:DHA, carob pulp extractPeople / Paden Reich

Best SerumTypology Self-Tanning SerumPHOTO: TypologyView on Typology.com

Best SerumTypology Self-Tanning Serum

Best Serum

Typology Self-Tanning Serum

PHOTO: Typology

View on Typology.com

Star QualitiesGlides easily onto skinLasts up to seven daysDoesn’t transfer onto clothing, towels, or sheetsCan be used alone or blended with moisturizerRed FlagsExpensive for a one-ounce bottle

Star QualitiesGlides easily onto skinLasts up to seven daysDoesn’t transfer onto clothing, towels, or sheetsCan be used alone or blended with moisturizer

Glides easily onto skin

Lasts up to seven days

Doesn’t transfer onto clothing, towels, or sheets

Can be used alone or blended with moisturizer

Red FlagsExpensive for a one-ounce bottle

Expensive for a one-ounce bottle

We loved the longevity and easy application of the Typology self-tanning serum. Since it has an oily texture, it applies smoothly to the skin for a deeper tan or mixes well with moisturizer for a more subtle glow. We found that it kept its integrity for seven days (and even once it started to fade, it still looked good). Despite having an oily texture, it absorbs quickly into the complexion and doesn’t transfer onto clothing or sheets. While it’s on the pricey side, the unique application and long-term results make this a worthwhile pick.

Size:1 ounce |Shades:One shade |Key Ingredients:DHA, carob pulp extract

People / Paden Reich

Best SplurgeLux Unfiltered N°12 Bronzing Face DropsPHOTO: Amazon$42 at Amazon$42 at SephoraView on Luxunfiltered.comStar QualitiesOnly takes 15 minutes to see resultsEasy to apply a natural-looking tanYou can mix this with a moisturizer for a more natural glowRed FlagsWe couldn’t find anyTheseself-tanning dropsare designed to mix into moisturizer or apply directly to the skin, depending on how deep you want your tan. It takes only 15 minutes to see results, and you can easily build upon your glow with daily use. In addition to tanning the skin, ingredients such as pomegranate extract, coconut water, passion fruit oil, vitamin E, and hyaluronic acid nourish and hydrate the skin, helping to support the skin’s overall glow.Size:1 ounce |Shades:One buildable shade |Key Ingredients:Pomegranate extract, coconut water, passion fruit oil, vitamin E, hyaluronic acidPeople / Sarah Felbin

Best SplurgeLux Unfiltered N°12 Bronzing Face DropsPHOTO: Amazon$42 at Amazon$42 at SephoraView on Luxunfiltered.com

Best SplurgeLux Unfiltered N°12 Bronzing Face Drops

Best Splurge

Lux Unfiltered N°12 Bronzing Face Drops

$42 at Amazon$42 at SephoraView on Luxunfiltered.com

Star QualitiesOnly takes 15 minutes to see resultsEasy to apply a natural-looking tanYou can mix this with a moisturizer for a more natural glowRed FlagsWe couldn’t find any

Star QualitiesOnly takes 15 minutes to see resultsEasy to apply a natural-looking tanYou can mix this with a moisturizer for a more natural glow

Only takes 15 minutes to see results

Easy to apply a natural-looking tan

You can mix this with a moisturizer for a more natural glow

Theseself-tanning dropsare designed to mix into moisturizer or apply directly to the skin, depending on how deep you want your tan. It takes only 15 minutes to see results, and you can easily build upon your glow with daily use. In addition to tanning the skin, ingredients such as pomegranate extract, coconut water, passion fruit oil, vitamin E, and hyaluronic acid nourish and hydrate the skin, helping to support the skin’s overall glow.

Size:1 ounce |Shades:One buildable shade |Key Ingredients:Pomegranate extract, coconut water, passion fruit oil, vitamin E, hyaluronic acid

People / Sarah Felbin

After you decide on a self-tanner, turn to these other PEOPLE-Tested beauty and wellness goods. Our team of experts puts each product through the paces to ensure they truly are the best in their respective categories.

Goop Beauty G.Tox Ultimate Dry Brush$25 at Amazon$25 at SephoraView on Fwrd.comL’Oreal Paris Revitalift Vitamin C Face Serum$36$27 at Amazon$36 at WalgreensView on Lorealparisusa.comRemington Deluxe Rechargeable Epilator$48 at AmazonView on Bkstr.comDrunk Elephant D-Bronzi Anti-Pollution Sunshine Drops$39$34 at Amazon$39 at Sephora$39 at Ulta

Goop Beauty G.Tox Ultimate Dry Brush$25 at Amazon$25 at SephoraView on Fwrd.com

Goop Beauty G.Tox Ultimate Dry Brush

$25 at Amazon$25 at SephoraView on Fwrd.com

L’Oreal Paris Revitalift Vitamin C Face Serum$36$27 at Amazon$36 at WalgreensView on Lorealparisusa.com

L’Oreal Paris Revitalift Vitamin C Face Serum

$36$27 at Amazon$36 at WalgreensView on Lorealparisusa.com

Remington Deluxe Rechargeable Epilator$48 at AmazonView on Bkstr.com

Remington Deluxe Rechargeable Epilator

$48 at AmazonView on Bkstr.com

Drunk Elephant D-Bronzi Anti-Pollution Sunshine Drops$39$34 at Amazon$39 at Sephora$39 at Ulta

Drunk Elephant D-Bronzi Anti-Pollution Sunshine Drops

$39$34 at Amazon$39 at Sephora$39 at Ulta

Other Self-Tanners We Tried

What to Know About Self-Tanners

Skincare Ingredients

When shopping for a self-tanner, Dr. Engelman says to look for “a self-tanning product that also doubles as skincare with ingredients that nourish and support the moisture barrier.” While not every self-tanner focuses on the inclusion of skincare ingredients, many top-rated formulas — including several on our list — boast hydrating benefits that contribute to that faux sun-kissed glow.

Our top pick for the best self-tanner overall, theBondi Sands Pure Self-Tanning Drops, features a blend of hyaluronic acid, vitamin C, and vitamin E to moisturize, nourish, and protect. And our best fragrance-free self-tanner, theTanologist Self-Tan Mousse, includes hyaluronic acid, vitamin C, and aloe vera for their hydrating, cooling, and glow-enhancing effects.

Texture and Type

A self-tanning product’s texture and application are also important to consider, as this can make or break a formula. “You want a smooth and seamless application for the most natural and beautiful-looking result possible,” says Dr. Engelman. With this in mind, she says to consider the different types of formulas and application processes, including lotions, sprays, serum drops, and mousse.

In addition to these popular formula types,Rachel Lee Lozina, a New York State licensed esthetician and owner of Blue Water Spa in Oyster Bay, N.Y., says to consider tan towels, which “are a quick and portable way to apply self-tanner,” as you can use them to quickly wipe your face, chest, arms, and legs for an on-the-go glow. Our top pick for the best self-tanning towelettes are theTan Towel Body Tan Towelettes, which come in a five-pack and aresupereasy to use.

Shade Range

“Self-tanners usually come in color choices, and you want to make sure you are choosing wisely,” says Lozina. She recommends starting with a lighter shade (especially if you’re new to self-tanner) since a shade that’s too dark for your skin tone won’t look natural, and it’s always easier to build upon. “If you feel it’s too light, you can always re-apply, but if you choose a shade too dark to start with, you have to wait for it to fade.”

While some self-tanners feature a range of different shades, others focus on more buildable or customizable coverage. For example, tanning drops are often used for more custom self-tans since the number of drops added to your moisturizer can result in a range of light to medium to deep finishes. Our top pick for the best self-tanner overall, theBondi Sands Pure Self-Tanning Drops, is an ideal example of this, as the instructions recommend adding four to 12 drops to moisturizer, depending on how deep you want your tan. TheIsle of Paradise Self-Tanning Body Dropsalso come in a serum-like bottle and three different shades for an even more custom glow.

Gradual and Buildable Shades

For those new to self-tanner or who are fair-skinned and nervous about not getting their shade right, Lozina says to consider lotions that gradually deepen over time or formulas with a more buildable process. “If your skin is very fair and you’re apprehensive about getting too dark too quickly, gradual creams are the best,” she explains. “Apply daily until you reach your desired tan, and then wait three to four days to reapply to maintain your perfect glow.”

Our PEOPLE Tested team researched the most popular self-tanners and tested 43 self-tanning formulas across a variety of categories, such as mousse, drops, foam, and towelettes, to find the best self-tanners. Over a two-week trial period, we made note of everything, including the application process, how well the formulas blended, whether or not they appeared streaky, how quickly they dried, and if they transferred to clothing, towels, and bedding. We rated each formula on a scale of 1 to 5 based on the following categories:

People / Brooke Ciolek

Frequently Asked Questions

This all depends on the formula and ingredients as well as your personal preferences. If you have sensitive skin, experts recommend always doing a patch test to see how your skin reacts before applying it all over. If fragrance is your biggest concern, it’s also best to look for a scent-free self-tanner such as theTanologist Self-Tan Mousse, which is fragrance-free and designed for sensitive skin types.

The best surface for self-tanner is clean, dry skin that is free from lotion, deodorant, and perfumes, saysLesly Frawley, owner of Namaste Tan in King of Prussia, Pa. “This will allow no barriers between the skin and sunless product to guarantee a natural finish,” she explains, noting that clean skin can also help prevent any blotchiness. However, if you tend to have too much color collect on areas of thick skin such as your knees, elbows, and heels, you can apply moisturizer there first to help dilute the color. We recommend exfoliating before application.

Jessie Quinnis a contributing commerce writer for PEOPLE and has written for publications such as Byrdie, InStyle, The Spruce, NYLON, and more. Jessie has experience covering top beauty products, like thebest epilatorsand thebest hair loss treatments. When covering the best self-tanners, Jessie reviewed and researched the PEOPLE Tested team’s insights, paying close attention to how well each self-tanning solution held up throughout the testing process. For further insight, Jessie also reached out to top skincare and self-tanning experts to learn more about what to look for in a self-tanner, the different types of self-tanners to consider, and what makes a self-tanning formula the best.

Our Expert PanelDr. Dendy Engelman, MD, FACMS, FAAD, is a board-certified cosmetic dermatologist and Mohs surgeon.Rachel Lee Lozinais a New York State licensed esthetician and owner of Blue Water Spa in Oyster Bay, N.Y.Lesly Frawleyis the owner of Namaste Tan in King of Prussia, Pa.

Our Expert Panel

Dr. Dendy Engelman, MD, FACMS, FAAD, is a board-certified cosmetic dermatologist and Mohs surgeon.Rachel Lee Lozinais a New York State licensed esthetician and owner of Blue Water Spa in Oyster Bay, N.Y.Lesly Frawleyis the owner of Namaste Tan in King of Prussia, Pa.

We created thePEOPLE Tested seal of approvalto help you find the very best products for your life. We use our unique methodology to test products in three labs across the country and with our network of home testers to determine their effectiveness, durability, ease of use, and so much more. Based on the results, we rate and recommend products so you can find the right one for your needs.

In short, PEOPLE Tested provides recommendations you can trust — every day, every purchase.

source: people.com